Custom Challenge Coins
Reviews and Complaints

This company is the real deal! I was blown away by their amazing service from start to finish. When I first reached out to them, they got back to me in a jiffy and gave me the best price around. And let me tell you, the first proof they sent me was absolutely perfect - the colors were spot on, the details were sharp, and everything was just right. I couldn't believe how easy and stress-free the whole process was!

I worked with a customer service rep named Matt Reilly, and he was an absolute gem. He was so patient with me and answered all of my questions quickly and professionally. And let me tell you, I had a lot of questions! But Matt never once made me feel like I was a bother or that my questions were silly. He was always there to help me out and make sure that I was happy with everything.

This was my first time ordering custom challenge coins, and I have to say, I was a little nervous about it. But the team at customchallengecoins.com made the whole experience a breeze. They were so helpful and friendly, and they really went above and beyond to make sure that I was happy with everything.

I can't recommend this company enough. If you're looking for high-quality custom challenge coins at a great price, look no further than customchallengecoins.com. They're the best in the business, and I know that I'll be coming back to them for all of my future coin needs. Thanks again, guys!

I don't usually write reviews, but I gotta say, the service with Custom Challenge Coins was top-notch. I've been working on my design for months, taking my sweet time, and every time I had a question, the staff was on it like white on rice. They kept track of all my designs and responded in just a few minutes. That's some lightning-fast customer service right there.

When I was finally ready to order, the directions were crystal clear and easy to follow. I appreciate that kind of simplicity, you know? Thanks for everything, guys!

I can't wait to see my coin and the looks on my colleagues' faces when they get 'em. It's gonna be epic.

Respectfully,
Kevin Seery

This project was a real doozy for me, it took nearly 2 YEARS to get it done, but it wasn't Custom Challenge Coins' fault at all. It was just the way things go when you're trying to turn ideas into reality. But let me tell you, having MATT R as our rep at Custom Challenge Coins was a godsend. He was so patient with us, even though we had a ton of proofs to go through before we were all happy with the final product.

I gotta say, I was really impressed with the level of professionalism and patience that MATT R showed us. He really went above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied with everything. And the end result? Let's just say it exceeded my expectations in every way possible.

If you're looking for a company that knows how to deliver quality products and top-notch service, then look no further than Custom Challenge Coins. They really know their stuff and they're not afraid to go the extra mile to make sure their customers are happy. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a professional organization that knows how to get things done right.

I gotta say, out of all the companies I got proofs from, Custom Challenge Coins was the best at bringing my design to life. Their proof team was on point, always responding super fast and making all my crazy requests happen. Yeah, they were a bit pricier than another company I was looking at, but dang, their response time was so good it made the other guys look like they were drawing with their feet.

I'm feeling pretty optimistic about this whole thing. If the coins look as good as the proofs, we're gonna have one heck of a coin on our hands. I'm stoked to keep working with these guys after we get our first run of coins. But hey, no pressure or anything, Custom Challenge Coins. I'm counting on you to keep up the good work!

I heard about Custom Challenge Coins from a retired Marine buddy of mine. He showed me his coin and I was impressed with how it looked. It had a nice polish that made it stand out. He gave me the 800 phone number and I called to talk to Barry Rainwater about getting a coin for myself. Barry was really knowledgeable and walked me through the whole process. It was pretty easy and I ended up saving some money by using the same front mold as my friend's coin.

Barry explained everything to me in a way that was easy to understand. He sent me an email quote and proof within two hours of my call. The proof looked great, but I wanted to make one change. I received another proof shortly after and it looked perfect. I ordered my coins from the comfort of my own home and everything was handled very professionally.

I really appreciated how easy it was to work with Custom Challenge Coins. The proofs looked serious and professional. I highly recommend this company to anyone looking for high-quality challenge coins.

Holy cow, I gotta say, Custom Challenge Coins is the real deal!

Their website was super easy to navigate and had all the info I needed right there. I even called up their customer service to double check and they were totally on point. Barry was a cool dude and answered all my questions with a smile.

They sent me proofs and a quote within 24 hours, and when I asked for a couple small tweaks, they had it done the same day! These guys work fast and their graphic designers are top notch. Our seal looked way better than anything we got from other companies we checked out.

All in all, this was an awesome experience and I'm definitely gonna tell all my friends about Custom Challenge Coins. We're already planning on using them for our next order and I'm gonna spread the word to all the other local government departments.

Big thanks to Barry and the graphic designers at Custom Challenge Coins! You guys rock!

I was looking for a Custom Challenge Coin site to help me with my project, and I reached out to another site first. Unfortunately, I didn't hear back from them for a whole 30 hours. So, I decided to try the next site on my list, which was customchallengecoins.com. I went to their getting started section and submitted my base design and ideas. To my surprise, I received a call within 5 minutes (or maybe it was 2, I can't remember exactly) and it was the boss himself who answered the phone. He was very concerned about my timing and assured me that he and his team would do everything they could to make sure my project was a success.

I was impressed by the direct contact and understanding of the process that I received right from the start. We were able to complete the graphics and design in a single afternoon, which was a great feeling in this day and age. I am now eagerly waiting for my coin, which looks even better than I imagined thanks to the design team's work. I have been telling all my friends who are interested in coins about this site, and I plan to place many more orders in the future.

It's a huge bonus when you feel like a company is working for your best interest, and that's exactly how I felt with customchallengecoins.com. I appreciate their dedication to making sure my project was a success, and I look forward to working with them again in the future. Thanks so much!

I had a really great experience with Custom Challenge Coins. A couple of my colleagues at work had recommended them to me after they had placed an order and were really pleased with the final product. So, I decided to give them a try and I'm so glad I did!

I did have some questions and needed some guidance, so I contacted their customer service team. I spoke with a guy named Barry a few times and he was super helpful. He really went above and beyond to make sure I was happy with everything. It was so nice to be able to talk to a real person and not have to deal with some automated system. Thank you, Barry!

The graphics production was really fast, too. I mean, like lightning fast. They sent me several different proofs and each time it only took a couple of hours to get them back to me. If the actual coins turn out as nice as the graphics, I know everyone who receives one will be really happy.

Overall, I had a really easy time working with Custom Challenge Coins and I would definitely use them again for future projects. Thanks, y'all!

Wow! I gotta say, Custom Challenge Coins is the real deal! They were super quick to respond and totally professional. I didn't even have to give them too much info and they knew exactly what I was looking for. They even gave me an alternate proof that was spot on! And let me tell you, I'm a pretty picky person, but they were so patient with me and made all the revisions I requested.

But what really impressed me was their honesty. They didn't just tell me what they could do, they also told me what they couldn't do. That kind of candor and integrity is hard to come by these days. And to top it all off, they caught a typo that I missed and fixed it before sending out my order. Talk about attention to detail!

I'm so happy with my coins that I'm already planning on using them for my next set. And let me tell you, make sure you're on the right site when you're ordering from these guys. There are a bunch of imitators out there with similar names, but these guys are the real deal. Don't settle for anything less!

I gotta say, these guys at Custom Challenge Coins are the real deal. I tried a few other companies and they were all giving me the runaround. But these guys, they were easy to deal with. I sent in my design and they got back to me that same day with a proof. No fuss, no muss. That's what I'm talking about.

And the price? Let me tell you, it was hard to beat. I got quotes from a bunch of other places and these guys were the cheapest for what I wanted. And the quality? Top notch. I was blown away by what they came up with. And they gave me plenty of time to make changes and decide on what I wanted. No pressure, no hassle.

The design team did an awesome job on my coin. I know it wasn't the most complicated design, but they really nailed it. And Matt Reilly, he was great to deal with. Anytime I had a question, he was quick to respond. I'm already thinking about getting another coin made for my home station in Japan and you can bet I'll be contacting these guys again.

Thanks again for all the help, Custom Challenge Coins. You guys rock.

SSgt Gregory Arnold
USAF

The checkout process on Custom Challenge Coins website is a bit of a hassle. It can be quite annoying to navigate through the different pages and options. One thing that could be improved is the payment options. It would be great if they could add a PayPal option so that customers can have a more secure and trustworthy payment method.

However, despite the checkout process being a bit of a pain, the quality of the challenge coins is top-notch. The designs are unique and the colors are vibrant. The coins are also very durable and can withstand wear and tear.

Another thing that sets Custom Challenge Coins apart from other companies is their customer service. They are very responsive and helpful when it comes to answering questions and addressing concerns. They also offer a wide range of customization options, so you can create a truly unique and personalized challenge coin.

Overall, if you're looking for high-quality challenge coins with excellent customer service, Custom Challenge Coins is definitely worth checking out. Just be prepared to deal with a slightly frustrating checkout process.

I gotta say, I'm pretty happy with the way things went down with Custom Challenge Coins. I've ordered from them twice now and both times have been pretty smooth sailing. The first time I had a little issue, but when I let them know about it, they took care of it without any hassle or argument. That's the kind of customer service that really makes a difference, you know? So I'm giving them four stars for that. Keep up the good work, Custom Challenge Coins!

They were quick to respond and very helpful in answering my questions. The ordering process was easy and straightforward, and I appreciated the ability to customize my challenge coins to my exact specifications.

The quality of the coins was top-notch, and I was impressed with the level of detail that was included in the design. The colors were vibrant and the text was crisp and clear. I was also happy with the weight and feel of the coins - they felt substantial and well-made.

Overall, I would highly recommend Custom Challenge Coins to anyone looking for high-quality, customizable challenge coins. While the online quote form may have had some issues, the sales team was quick to respond and made the ordering process a breeze. The end result was a set of beautiful coins that exceeded my expectations.