Steel City Collectibles
Reviews and Complaints

I bought lots of card boxes from Steel City Collectibles. They ship fast and pack good. They even helped me out when I called about a card. They're a great company. I always buy from them online. 5 stars!

Steel City Collectibles for making our gift giving easy and stress-free. We love their selection and the fact that they have signed cards from all our grandson's favorite players. The prices are good and the shipping is fast. We've never had any issues with our orders and the packaging is always top-notch. We highly recommend Steel City Collectibles for anyone looking for signed sports memorabilia.

I heard they buy signed stuff, but when I hit them up they didn't seem too interested. I offered cash, trade, or store credit, but they just sent me a lame email saying they're not interested. It was a bummer.

FROM STEEL CITY COLLECTIBLES! They're a bunch of cheaters who don't care about their customers. I wasted my hard-earned money on their worthless packs. Don't make the same mistake as me. Stay away from these crooks!

My buddy bought 40 silver packs from Steel City Collectibles for the 2022 Nationals. Each set of 10 cost over $500. But guess what? Every single card was paper! No foils at all. And of course, no autos either. They even did this on a live break that someone bought. They only got one auto card. These guys are total scammers. Who knows what else they've done to rip off honest folks like us. Stay away from these jerks at all costs!

This company is awesome! I buy stuff from them every month and they always ship it out fast. If they got it in stock, I usually get it the next day. They're good at finding stuff I want and their prices are fair. They're a business, so they gotta make money, but they're not greedy. I never had a problem getting stuff that's in stock. They even gave me a refund once for a messed up presell item. If you're into sports cards, this is the only place to go!

I bought a Topps Chrome Sapphire edition box from Steel City Collectibles on 11/15 for $489.95. But, it didn't come even after 10 days. I contacted Steel City, and they said it was delivered on November 18. But, it wasn't. I called them, and they asked me to send an email. I did, but they replied saying it's not their problem. I spent $489.95 on a Christmas gift for my son, and they won't help me or investigate what happened. I filed a complaint with the post office, and they're investigating. I disputed the charge with my credit card, but Steel City accused me of scamming them. Don't buy from this company. We lost a lot of money, and something's fishy about them.

They got a lot of cool stuff, like sports cards and memorabilia. The prices are pretty fair, but sometimes they can be a bit steep. The shipping is usually pretty quick, but sometimes it takes a while. Overall, I'd say they're a solid choice for collectors.

I spent like $600 on Steel City Collectibles and then they sent me an email the next day saying they canceled everything and gave me only $300 back. I used my own card and now I can't even buy it back. Not cool.

I bought a bunch of sports cards from Steel City Collectibles, but I never got them. It cost me a lot of money, like 1400 bucks. They said they sent it to some place in New Jersey, but I don't know that place and I don't live there. They just said sorry and that they had tracking. But you need to sign for something that expensive, and I didn't sign for it 'cause I don't live in New Jersey. They haven't even tried to figure out who got my stuff. I think they messed up and put the wrong address on my account. I've bought stuff from them before and it was all good, but this time it was a real bummer.

I bought stuff from this company but it ain't come yet. It's been 16 days since it was supposed to get here. I tried to get in touch with them like 6 or 7 times but they didn't answer. Finally they emailed me back but it wasn't much help. We went back and forth for a few days but they just kept sending me the same email over and over. I asked them to give me my money back since I never got the stuff but they said they gotta charge me a 10% fee. That ain't right. I paid for the stuff to be delivered and it ain't my fault it never got here. I even paid extra for Priority Mail and it still didn't come. Now they wanna charge me for the delivery and a restocking fee. Can someone help me with this?

I made 10 orders in 5 days and saw that the tracking said USPS First Class instead of UPS Expedted which I paid for. I told them and they canceled the label but didn't give me a new one. They just put it in another order I made and paid for separate expedited shipping. I made many orders over 5 days, choosing to ship each one separately and paying $11.64 for expedited UPS on each order. They decided to combine all 7 orders into 3 packages without telling me. They didn't even give me a refund for the difference and kept the money. I tried to contact them but they blocked me on YouTube & Twitch and won't answer my emails. They also blocked me from buying which is a problem because I have a lot of "loyalty points" that I should be able to use. It was a terrible experience and I wonder how long they've been doing this without customers noticing the extra charges.