Menu
Login
Having been Sky customers for many years and avid Golf viewers, why do we now have to endure Alison Whitaker an opinionated woman with a terrible loud Grating voice/accent that makes my wife an I look for the mute button! Her grammar is awful and she continually introduces booming interferences of Sky's excellent commentators. How do people as bad as her manage to find their way on to a Sky platform?
Please replace her ASAP.
P and M Murphy
Fox TV
439 reviews
Service Electric
6 reviews
OpticalTel
11 reviews
KyLinTV
22 reviews
Sling TV
156 reviews
Totally agree with the comments about Alison Whitaker she doesn’t sit well with me and my partner Chris former Captain of his club & very keen golfer I believe she got the job merely because she’s a woman which appears to be a running theme at present which is unacceptable we pay a great deal in Sky subscriptions therefore the customer deserves the best! And unfortunately Alison is not it.
Dear oh dear in this day and age you very bigoted people can't make remarks like this. Alison is a breath of fresh air on SKY. The simple answer is swith off and do everyone a favour and come into the 21st century because clearly you have nothing worth saying
I totally agree with the negative comments about Alison Whitaker . She is an appalling awful golf commentator and should be taken off the air immediately. I want to be able watch golf again without having my finger on the mute button. Her voice is irritating, her comments are both irrelevant and pretentious and she never stops talking - she has a severe case of verbal diarrhoea. I am an Australian female for the record.
Bernadette
Don't you dare sack her. She's brilliant
She's awful, stating the bleeding obvious in her very irritating, rasping voice.
She's awful, stating the bleeding obvious in her very irritating, rasping voice.
Again I beg you please get Alison Whitaker off the air so I can watch European golf without having my finger on the mute button. I just want to listen to the dulcet tones of British commentators.
She never stops talking in a grating, irritating high pitched loud voice, more suited to foot brawl commentating! When not stating the obvious, she indulges in irrelevant chatter.
The same style of commentating applies to Ian Baker-Finch who should be removed from the USA commentating team before my mute button completely dies.
Have to agree with the negative comments, she’s horrendous. Virtually everything she talks about is what the viewer is seeing with their eyes.
I’m a former broadcast journalist and the art of good commentary is adding value to what the viewer sees by adding to that.
Alternatively she just trumpet stats, Cam Smith currently no.1ranked Aussie golfer, Terrell Hayton currently no.1 ranked English golfer.
This isn’t woman bashing either, Karen Stupples is on course at the open is awesome, she adds value.
Alison Whitaker never does and stop start tone only makes it harder to listen too, gag her!
Totally agree. I'm sure she's a lovely girl and she certainly has golfing knowledge, but she needs to learn to let the golf do the talking. Take a breather. We don't need to hear every little detail about every player while they're hitting. We want to hear the crisp sound of the ball on the club, or the murmor of the crowd. Her levels are also extremely offensive as is her regular emphasis on the wrong words within sentences. My whole extended family have to switch off when she's in the box.
Please, please get a replacement for this woman. I am sure that she is very nice but totally unsuitable for commentating the golf tournaments. She never shuts up and comes up with a lot of drivel and has the most irritating voice. My mute button is worn out!
Happy to find this complaints board she is dreadful and completely ruins the otherwise great coverage ... please find an alternative ASAP
Omg. She's doing 4 hour + stints dominating the commentary like no one ever before this British Open. She won't stop talking. Her levels are erratic. We've all tried muting the telecast but we need the crowd noise and ambience. Surely the telecaat team can see how irritating her commentary is for the viewers. Ratings are heading south 😪
Omg. You've got to be joking. Now she's doing the Olympic golf. 🤷♂️ give some other ladies a go in the commentary box... please!
She is shocking and her opinions are not based on life knowledge. Just a chancer.
I find her very pleasant and easy … not like the bloody yanks and their “ great shot right there” I mean seriously .She fits in very well with the other Euro commentary team who do a superb job compared to the US commentators .
We are trying to watch the Solheim Cup, and the cover is being` Ruined `by this Allison Whitaker, why do we have to listen to her terrible Australian voice? very poor commentry, frequently not on what we want to hear but on just what she wants to blab about, bragging about her personal acces to the golfers, god help the poor golfers. Much of it seems personal information that she should not be airing. We are not paying for a third rate service, so will Sky please remove this irritating person and replace her with one of the other excelent commentators Sky use! While you are at it, remove the American male commentator covering the Italian Open who is nearly as bad as Whitaker! Continuingly interupting the other commentators and trying to take control of the programme. Rubish Commentators, do Sky MKanagement read these complaints, they are the tip of an Iceberg!
Maggie M
Please PLEASE tell Ms. Whitaker to stop constantly talking! I wish her only the best on this planet but she is a terrible golf commentator.
It's such a shame for the sport. She's making it so tough for us to just relax and enjoy the golf. So loud and irritating. Someone needs to teach her less is better when it comes to golf commentary. Maybe give her the hosting role back in the studio, but please not the commentary box.
I need to reply to you even though I saw your comment a fair bit ago... While I agree regarding Allison Whittaker I beg to differ greatly on the excellent commentry skills of Jay Townsend.. the man is a genius & knows the game inside out & believe me he shows up Ms Whittaker which is what we want to move her to pastures new. It shouldn't matter whether Ms Whittaker is an Aussie or Jay is an American, the thread here is how good or indeed how bad is Ms Whittaker when commentating on male golf. Good day to you
A breath air at ZOZO. Fun, knowledgeable and gives the broadcast son life.
Having listened to Alison Nicholas commentating at the Zozo golf in Japan I'm still waiting for the ' awful grammar' alleged by P & M Murphy.
Maybe you prefer her to start every sentence with 'so', throw in a 'double negative' every second sentence, confuse her'tenses' and end every comment with 'as well' ?
Let's face it, the English have worse grammar than most English speaking countries!
Whether you think she is 'loud' or 'opinionated' or 'talks too much' is personal choice.
We all have our favourites & those we prefer to 'mute' out!
No, I'm not Australian but many British would benefit from their education system.
I agree with the thread title. Alison Whitaker talks far too much, has an irksome tone and does not add much value to the pictures. She lessens the generally pleasant experience of watching and listening to Sky Sports golf. If TV companies could monitor the use of home mute buttons, they might see heavy usage of such once Ms Whitaker takes her turn in the commentator's box. Holding a reasonable and reasoned view does not equate to bigotry. The mass labelling of people who disagree with you (as per the above poster) certainly does.
Please make here stop, ruining the golf truly awful.
Please get rid of this awful annoying women, first time I have had to mute the sound after 25 years watching sky golf .
Absolutely agree. She is dreadful and hogs the commentary box. I’ve never heard of her prior to her being part of the commentary team. Not only does she grate but she also adds nothing whatsoever to the pictures.
Absolutely agree
Don’t doubt her knowledge of golf but her voice is so irritating and she does not know when to stop talking
Sky has some great announcers why not use them
Allison Whittaker has to be the most annoying voice ever to commentate on golf.my mute button is almost worn out.
Cannot agree more. She will be responsible for people not wanting to watch the DP Tour anymore.
Totally agree with P and M Murray
So many inane statements from Alison Whitaker
Please Alison Whitaker, shutup. Please just shutup.
Yes I’m sorry, I must agree with most comments on here…after consideration I make this observation….
I believe she feels like she must keep talking to add to the broadcast, but reality is, keep it short and sharp, let every middle aged male golfer watching get used to your voice and you may stand a chance……!? Less is more…
The way she currently goes about it does make me want to use the mute button. Which is a shame as I feel the European broadcast is generally the best in the world! Cheers
I agree completely regarding Alison Whitaker's golf commentaries..she is so irritating and constantly trying to better the men but she was no match for the brilliant Jay Townsend last week. I will also say that the male commentators are very tame when with Whitaker and where is Jay Townsend for the Scottish Open
This is my second plea to the powers that be to remove Whitiaker she is truly awful and ruins the otherwise excellent commentary team.
Please please save us from her dreadful commentary
Oh no Whitikar at the Open how to ruin a celebration of mens golf
She is bloody awful
I could not agree more, she is absoulatey dreadful, very wooden in style. Please remove her. C Mc Gowan
My father and I fight to hit the mute button! and she is doing nothing for our swearing! Grating voice and just the most stupid and vapid comments….just won’t stop talking and stating the most obvious points! Be quiet! Please!
That grating aussie voice from a girl who speaks like she’s got credentials for a touring pro level swing analyst is more than I can take. Add the fact the [censored] never goes home to that island who has rolled over and let the government [censored] them in the [censored] then piss on their faces. Go home you awful woman. You suck as a golf commentator your voice and comments blow bad and you are [censored]ING EVERYWHERE
Take a year off !
Alison Whittaker is merely copying the men's golfing terminology. The brilliant Jay Townsend recently said "right in the Jaws" referring to a putt and Alison who was a co commentator suddenly started to use the word "Jaws" she should be commentating on the women's game not the men's. It's not natural for women to talk like men and female golfing terminology is awful. Of course male comments can be off the wall and very comical whereas Alison is trying to be professional.
Alison Whittaker should not be commentating on men's golf. She is very poor and is continually looking for coroboration from her male colleagues after making some comment. It's not about good or bad, it's that male terminology is just way different from women's.
Alison Whitaker is the absolute pits of a commentator. I cannot stand that horrid voice and her mainly boring and ridiculous comments.
Sky tv, why don’t you employ someone from the UK to do the job instead of a loud mouthed Australian.
GET RID OF HER.
I just want to add this regarding the Italian Open day 3, why is Jay Townsend sent out on the course, he is by far and away the best golf commentator.. with all this equality going on why wasn't Alison Whittaker sent out. This nonsense of pandering to women is embarrassing and destroying sport in general.
Why are you persisting with Alison Whittaker as a male golf commentator. Jay Townsend should be given much more commentary but instead you have practically muted him and Whittaker can't close her mouth. I just want to listen to the men's golf with the male quips and excellent commentary that as always been part and parcel of our game. We don't want a female trying to butt in. Alison is made for the women's game. It's obvious the guys are afraid to express themselves with her around so give us and them a break.
Please send Alison Whittaker out on the course and please stop sending Jay, it's a complete insult to him. She is better seen and not heard whereas Jay should be heard all the time. Get a grip and do what most viewers want and send Alison to the women's game. It's time to stand up to this equality nonsense. It seems you are afraid to have Jay in the commentary box because he would show up Alison's poor comments.
I was looking forward to relaxing and watching the French Open Golf but you have destroyed it for those of us avid golf fans by having Alison Whittaker as a commentator once again. She should be doing womens golf not the male game. I turned it off for the last 2 hours and now I am watching the finish on Day 1, she is still mouthing off and there is no sign of Jay. Please get rid of her. She of course will get away with it with newcomers to golf but not to guys and gals who live and love the game.
Once she starts Alison Whittaker just doesn't know how to shut up, she has a mouthful of statistics but in male golf you need much more. She has ridiculous comments like a few moments ago she went on about how Hajgaard, the overnight leader by about 7 shots, had all night to think about it... Would someone please tell her this isn't the final day.. it was natural for Hajgaard to come back to the field after his amazing 15 under for the first 2 days. All the guys kept quiet, no one wants to cross a woman in these crazy times. Please put her onto the woman's tour and tell her it's a promotion.
Horrible Australian accent, boring and pits me off watching sky golf, get rid of her!